Your Cart

The Complete Guide to Choosing an Engagement Ring

Nov 21, 2024

Jake Eisenberg

You've found the one, and now it's time to find the perfect ring to symbolize your love. But with so many options available, choosing an engagement ring can feel a bit daunting. Don't worry, we're here to help! 

This guide will walk you through everything you need to know, from understanding your partner's style to exploring the 4Cs of diamonds (and beyond!). We'll cover popular styles, different gemstones, and even offer tips for making the ring-buying experience enjoyable and stress-free. Let's get started!

Understanding Your Partner’s Style 

Choosing an engagement ring is a deeply personal decision. While your own taste is important, the ring should first and foremost reflect your partner's individual style. After all, they'll be wearing it every day! But how do you discover their preferences without spoiling the surprise? Here are a few subtle strategies:

  • Pay attention to their existing jewelry: What kind of metals and gemstones do they usually wear? Do they prefer simple, minimalist pieces or bold, statement designs?
  • Listen closely: Have they ever dropped hints about rings they admire? Perhaps they've commented on a friend's engagement ring or saved images online.
  • Enlist the help of friends and family: Their loved ones might have valuable insights into their jewelry preferences.
  • Consider their lifestyle: Are they active and outdoorsy? Do they work with their hands? A delicate ring might not be the best choice for someone with a very active lifestyle.
  • Consider their personality: Are they classic, traditional, modern, or unconventional? The ring should complement their personality and make them feel confident and beautiful.

Exploring Engagement Ring Styles

Now that you have a good sense of your partner's taste, let’s look into the different engagement ring styles to learn the distinct personality and charm of each. To help you navigate the options, we've put together a guide to some of the most popular choices:

Solitaire

This classic and timeless style features a single, stunning diamond (or other gemstone) set on a simple band. It's elegant and sophisticated, allowing the center stone to take center stage. 

Halo

Want extra sparkle? A halo setting encircles the center stone with a ring of smaller diamonds, creating a dazzling effect. This style tends to make the center stone appear more prominent, too!

Three-Stone

With a larger center stone and two smaller side stones, the three-stone setting symbolizes your love story's past, present, and future. It's a design filled with romance and meaning.

Pavé

For those who love a bit of extra glitz, pavé settings feature tiny diamonds set closely together along the band. This arrangement creates a continuous sparkle that beautifully complements the center stone.

Bezel

In a bezel setting, the center stone is surrounded by a thin metal rim, offering a modern and secure setting. This style is perfect for those with an active lifestyle, as it protects the stone from bumps and scratches.

Channel-Set

If you prefer a sleek and contemporary look, consider a channel setting. In this style, diamonds are set in a groove along the band, creating a clean and continuous line of sparkle.

Side-Stone

Similar to the three-stone setting, side-stone rings have smaller diamonds accenting the center stone. This adds extra sparkle and dimension to the ring.

Vintage Engagement Rings

If you're after a ring with a unique story, consider vintage engagement rings. These pieces often feature intricate details and antique cuts, making each a one-of-a-kind treasure.

Beyond these popular engagement ring styles, you'll find various other options, such as tension settings, cluster rings, and more. Browse our collection to explore different designs and find one that truly speaks to you and your partner. 

The 4 Cs of Diamonds

When it comes to diamond engagement rings, understanding the 4Cs is essential. These four factors—carat, cut, color, and clarity—determine a diamond's quality and value. Let's break them down:

Carat

A diamond’s weight is measured in carats, with one-carat equivalent to 200 milligrams. Although larger diamonds are often more expensive, it's important to consider the other Cs as well. A smaller diamond with excellent cut, color, and clarity can be more brilliant than a larger, lower-quality stone.

Cut

The cut of a diamond is arguably the most important factor, as it directly affects its brilliance and sparkle. A well-cut diamond reflects light internally, creating that dazzling play of light we all adore. Cut grades range from Excellent to Poor, with Excellent cuts maximizing brilliance. 

Color

Diamonds are graded on a color scale, ranging from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow). Colorless diamonds are generally more valuable, but near-colorless diamonds can offer excellent value and beauty. Ultimately, the choice depends on your preference. 

Clarity

Natural diamonds often have tiny imperfections called inclusions. Clarity refers to the number and visibility of these inclusions. Diamonds with fewer inclusions are generally more valuable. However, many inclusions are invisible to the naked eye and don't significantly affect a diamond's beauty; they simply add to its unique character.

Finding the perfect diamond is about balancing the 4Cs to match your budget and priorities. Don't hesitate to ask your jeweler for guidance and view diamonds with different characteristics to see the differences firsthand.

Exploring Other Gemstones

While diamonds remain a classic choice for engagement rings, they're certainly not the only option! Many couples are now embracing colorful gemstones, adding a unique and personal touch to their rings. Choosing an engagement ring with a gemstone allows you to express your own style and create a truly unique piece. Here are a few popular choices:

  • Sapphires: Known for their rich blue hues, sapphires symbolize loyalty and trust. They're also incredibly durable, making them a practical choice for everyday wear.
  • Emeralds: With their vibrant green color, emeralds represent growth and new beginnings, perfect for embarking on a lifelong journey together.
  • Rubies: The fiery red of ruby symbolizes passion and love. This bold and romantic gemstone makes a striking statement.
  • Moissanite: A shimmering alternative to diamonds, moissanite offers exceptional brilliance and fire at a more affordable price point.

You can also consider other gemstones like morganite, aquamarine, or even your partner's birthstone. Incorporating a birthstone adds a personal touch and creates a meaningful connection.

Pro Tip: Gemstones provide a wonderful opportunity to play with different engagement ring styles. Imagine a vibrant ruby in a classic halo setting or a deep blue sapphire in a vintage-inspired design! The possibilities are endless.

Metals and Settings

The metal and setting of an engagement ring also play a significant role in its overall look, durability, and comfort. Let's explore the key factors to consider:

Metals

  • Platinum: Known for its strength and natural white sheen, platinum is a popular choice for engagement rings. It's hypoallergenic and requires less maintenance than other metals.
  • Gold: Available in various colors (yellow, white, and rose), gold offers a classic and timeless look. Choose the karat that suits your budget and preference, with higher karats indicating a higher gold content.
  • Palladium: A member of the platinum family, palladium offers a similar white color and durability at a more affordable price point.

Settings

  • Prong: This classic setting uses tiny metal claws (prongs) to secure the center stone, allowing maximum light to pass through.
  • Bezel: As mentioned earlier, a bezel setting encircles the stone with a metal rim, offering a modern and protective design.
  • Channel: Ideal for accent stones, a channel setting secures gems within a groove in the band, creating a sleek and continuous line.
  • Pave: This setting features tiny diamonds set closely together, adding extra sparkle and dimension to the ring.

When choosing a metal and setting, consider your partner's lifestyle, preferences, and the overall style of the ring. For example, an active individual might prefer a durable platinum setting, while someone with a classic taste might prefer a yellow gold prong setting.

Custom Engagement Rings

For a truly personal symbol of your love, consider custom engagement rings. With a custom design, you have complete control over every detail, from the shape and size of the center stone to the intricate details of the setting. Perhaps you want to incorporate family heirlooms or design a ring that reflects a shared passion or memory. 

Think of it as a collaborative work of art. You bring your ideas and inspiration, and the jeweler provides expertise and handiwork to transform your vision into a tangible symbol of your commitment. The result? A one-of-a-kind ring that tells your unique love story.

Engagement Ring Shopping Tips

Ready to start your engagement ring shopping adventure? Here are some tips to make the experience enjoyable and successful:

  • Set a Budget: Determine a realistic budget early on and stick to it. This will help you narrow down your options and avoid overspending.
  • Do Your Research: Take the time to research reputable jewelers in your area or online. Read reviews and compare prices to find a jeweler you trust.
  • Consider Lifestyle: Think about your partner's lifestyle and how the ring will fit into their everyday activities. An active person might prefer a more durable setting, while someone who works with their hands might opt for a simpler design.
  • Think About Ring Size: Try to discreetly determine your partner's ring size. You can ask a friend or family member for help or "borrow" a ring they wear regularly to get it sized.
  • Prioritize Comfort: The ring should not only look beautiful but also feel comfortable to wear. Consider the width of the band and the setting style to ensure a comfortable fit.
  • Get an Appraisal: Once you've purchased the ring, have it appraised for insurance purposes. This will protect your investment in case of loss or damage.
  • Don't Rush: Take your time and enjoy the process! Choosing an engagement ring is a significant decision, so don't feel pressured to rush into a purchase.

These engagement ring shopping tips will help you confidently navigate the process and find the perfect ring. But most importantly, have fun! This is an exciting time. Enjoy discovering a ring that reflects your unique love story. Ask questions, explore options, and trust your instincts to find the ring that speaks to your heart.

Caring for your Engagement Ring

You've found the perfect ring; let's ensure it stays sparkling for years! Proper care is essential to maintain its beauty and brilliance. Here's how:

  • Regular Cleaning: Gently clean your ring with warm, soapy water and a soft brush. You can also use a jewelry cleaning solution specifically designed for your ring's metal and gemstones.
  • Professional Care: Schedule professional cleanings and inspections with your jeweler every six months to ensure the setting is secure and the stones are sparkling.
  • Safe Storage: When not in use, store your ring in a soft pouch or lined jewelry box to prevent scratches and damage.
  • Avoid Harsh Chemicals: Remove your ring before using harsh chemicals or engaging in activities that could expose it to impact or abrasion.

Proper care will protect your investment and keep your ring looking its best. After all, it's a symbol of your love story and a piece you'll cherish long after you've said "I do" and started browsing for the best Chicago wedding bands!

Bring Home the Perfect Engagement Ring Today! 

Choosing an engagement ring is an incredible journey. It's about finding a symbol that reflects your partner's style, love story, and commitment to a lifetime together.

From exploring different styles and gemstones to understanding the 4Cs of diamonds, we've covered the essentials to guide you through the process. Remember to consider your partner's preferences, trust your instincts, and enjoy this special time.

Ready to find the perfect ring? Visit our store or browse our stunning collection online. At Bryn Mawr, we're not just the best place to buy wedding rings; we're where your forever begins. 

Contact us to book an appointment today! 

company-logo

Bryn Mawr Jewelry Co. is a luxury diamond jewelry house known for its exceptional fine jewelry and timeless designs.

Contact Us

Bryn Mawr Jewelry Co.
5139 N. Clark St.
Chicago, Illinois 60640

Our Hours

Monday Closed

Tuesday to Friday 11 - 7pm

Saturday 11 - 5pm

Sunday 12 - 4pm

Follow Us

card-logo